Ranked on the gates, not on charm. Every one of these has one specific unknown named, and every unknown closes with a phone call or a records request you can make yourself.
1 · Lot 3 Silvest Road, Orondo — $599,000
The only candidate where the dock path is proven on the governing document, not merely hoped for.
Chelan PUD's Rocky Reach manual asks "Is it still possible to apply for a dock permit?" and answers "Yes." FERC Article 410(b)(2) lets the PUD approve a dock of ten watercraft or fewer without FERC review at all, and the mapped shoreline class here is Integrated Use — the widest range of private and commercial uses. Add: the county assesses it at $686,000 and it asks $599,000; it is the highest-valued of the five lots, which independently confirms your read; 48 minutes on one highway with no pass; a protected cove where the pool moved 0.29 ft in 24 hours; and unincorporated Douglas County has no short-term-rental ordinance at all — no caps, no queue, and a CUP that runs with the land. The one thing to close: all five lots come from a September 2025 tax segregation with a blank plat name. They may not be legal lots of record. Call Douglas County Planning before you book a showing.
2 · 200 Stayman Flats Rd, Chelan — $549,000
The only VERIFIED property on the board, and the only one where a dock and a sandy beach are both already there.
Three independent sources plus a county assessor check. "Low-bank access, a sandy beach, and… a private dock." An hour away, on the Columbia, and it does not carry the "deeded access" flag that killed 24 Elite Drive. To close: is the existing dock authorised or merely existing? Title report plus the county shoreline file. It is bare land, so the hideout gets built.
3 · Rilette Springs — $799,900
Zero gate failures — the only property in the set with none.
Dock, launch, beach, cabin, well, septic, power and the RV all exist today. And Rufus Woods turns out to be the rare water where fishing and swimming can share a beach, because no salmon run means no salmon armada. To close: the Corps outgrant does not automatically transfer — make it a condition of closing and value the dock at zero until it is in hand. Town scores 1 of 5, and that is the real cost.
4 · Whiskey Ridge — $2,325,000 · your favorite
Not because it is weak — because it is priced 15–30% above what two independent methods defend, with no exit.
The entire active market on that water is seven town lots worth $1.8M combined; this one parcel asks 1.28× all of it. The play the research recommends: buy Rilette Springs, and take an option or right of first refusal on the 472. Same seller, one negotiation, 474 days on market, seller carry already volunteered. Do not open at ask.
5 · Lot 1 Silvest — $549,000 · 6 · 1307 Jefferson Ave — $875,000 · 7 · 2570 Emerson Acres — $449,000
The honest middle.
Lot 1 asks 84% of assessed — the deepest discount of the five — same proven dock path, but the end lot rather than the cove's middle. 1307 Jefferson has the best lodging law in the region and a dock gate that now needs the community-dock route. Emerson Acres is the cheapest dock on Lake Chelan with $25K of engineering already paid — and no water right yet.